Home About Network of subjects Linked subjects heatmap Book indices included Search by subject Search by reference Browse subjects Browse texts

Tiresias: The Ancient Mediterranean Religions Source Database



4413
Demosthenes, Orations, 21.50-21.61


nanIf the barbarians heard these words and understood their import, do you not think that they would unanimously appoint you their protectors? πρόξενος, here loosely used, is technically a man chosen by a foreign state as its representative in his own native city (nearly a consul in the modern sense). As regards this law then, which is so well esteemed among the Greeks and would be well esteemed among the barbarians also, consider what penalty he who transgresses it will have to pay before he has paid his deserts.


nanNow if I had not been chorus-master, men of Athens, when I was thus maltreated by Meidias, it is only the personal insult that one would have condemned; but under the circumstances I think one would be justified in condemning also the impiety of the act. You surely realize that all your choruses and hymns to the god are sanctioned, not only by the regulations of the Dionysia, but also by the oracles, in all of which, whether given at Delphi or at Dodona, you will find a solemn injunction to the State to set up dances after the ancestral custom, to fill the streets with the savour of sacrifice, and to wear garlands.


nanPlease take and read the actual oracles. The Oracles You I address, Pandion’s townsmen and sons of Erechtheus, who appoint your feasts by the ancient rites of your fathers. See you forget not Bacchus, and joining all in the dances Down your broad-spaced streets, in thanks ἱστάναι χάριν, if the Greek is sound, seems to be a portmanteau phrase to set up a dance in gratitude. The oracle quoted may perfectly well be genuine. for the gifts of the season, Crown each head with a wreath, while incense reeks on the altars. For health sacrifice and pray to Zeus Most High, to Heracles, and to Apollo the Protector; for good fortune to Apollo, god of the streets, to Leto, and to Artemis; and along the streets set wine-bowls and dances, and wear garlands after the manner of your fathers in honor of all gods and all goddesses of Olympus, raising right hands and left in supplication, Translating λιτάς, Weil ’s suggestion. and remember your gifts.


nanOracles from Dodona To the people of the Athenians the prophet of Zeus announces. Whereas ye have let pass the seasons of the sacrifice and of the sacred embassy, he bids you send nine chosen envoys, and that right soon. To Zeus of the Ship There was a temple at Dodona dedicated to Zeus under this title to commemorate a rescue from shipwreck. sacrifice three oxen and with each ox three sheep; to Dione one ox and a brazen table for the offering which the people of the Athenians have offered. The prophet of Zeus in Dodona announces. To Dionysus pay public sacrifices and mix a bowl of wine and set up dances; to Apollo the Averter sacrifice an ox and wear garlands, both free men and slaves, and observe one day of rest; to Zeus, the giver of wealth, a white bull.


nanBesides these oracles, men of Athens, there are many others addressed to our city, and excellent oracles they are. Now what conclusion ought you to draw from them? That while they prescribe the sacrifices to the gods indicated in each oracle, to every oracle that is published they add the injunction to set up dances and to wear garlands after the manner of our ancestors.


nanTherefore in the case of all the choruses that are constituted, together with their chorus-masters, during the days on which we meet in competition, these oracles make it clear that we wear our crowns as your representatives, the winner as well as the one destined to be last of all; it is not until the day of the prize-giving that the victor receives his own special crown. If, then, a man commits a malicious assault on any member or master of these choruses, especially during the actual contest in the sacred precinct of the god, can we deny that he is guilty of impiety?


nanMoreover, you are aware that, although anxious to exclude aliens from the contest, you do not grant unlimited right to any chorus-master to summon for scrutiny any member of a chorus If a chorus-master suspected that a member of a rival chorus was an alien, he must not forcibly eject him nor summon him before the Archon to prove his nationality. ; if he summons him, he is fined fifty drachmas, and a thousand drachmas if he orders him to sit among the spectators. What is the object? To protect the crowned official, who is doing public service to the god, from being maliciously summoned or annoyed or insulted on that day.


nanSo even the man who in due course of law summons a member of a chorus will not escape a fine. And shall not he be punished who in contempt of all the laws thus publicly strikes the master of a chorus? Surely it is useless for your laws to be thus well and humanely framed for the protection of the humbler citizen, if those who disobey and flout them are not to incur the resentment of you who are, for the time being, entrusted with their administration.


nanAnd now I solemnly call your attention to another point. I shall beg you not to be offended if I mention by name some persons who have fallen into misfortune; for I swear to you that in doing so I have no intention of casting reproach upon any man; I only want to show you how carefully all the rest of you avoid anything like violent or insulting behavior. There is, for instance, Sannio, the trainer of the tragic choruses, who was convicted of shirking military service and so found himself in trouble.


nanAfter that misfortune he was hired by a chorus-master—Theozotides, if I am not mistaken—who was keen to win a victory in the tragedies. Well, at first the rival masters were indignant and threatened to debar him, but when they saw that the theater was full and the crowd assembled for the contest, they hesitated, they gave way, and no one laid a finger on him. One can see that the forbearance which piety inspires in every one of you is such that Sannio has been training choruses ever since, not hindered even by his private enemies, much less by any of the chorus-masters.


nanThen again there is Aristeides of the tribe of Oeneis, who has had a similar misfortune. He is now an old man and perhaps less useful in a chorus, but he was once chorus-leader for his tribe. You know, of course, that if the leader is withdrawn, the rest of the chorus is done for. But in spite of the keen rivalry of many of the chorus-masters, not one of them looked at the possible advantage or ventured to remove him or prevent him from performing. Since this involved laying hands on him, and since he could not be cited before the Archon as if he were an alien whom it was desired to eject, every man shrank from being seen as the personal author of such an outrage.


nanThen is not this, gentlemen of the jury, a shocking and intolerable position? On the one hand, chorus-masters, who think that such a course might bring them victory and who have in many cases spent all their substance on their public services, have never dared to lay hands even on one whom the law permits them to touch, but show such caution, such piety, such moderation that, in spite of their expenditure and their eager competition, they restrain themselves and respect your wishes and your zeal for the festival. Meidias, on the other hand, a private individual who has been put to no expense, just because he has fallen foul of a man whom he hates—a man, remember, who is spending his money as chorus-master and who has full rights of citizenship—insults him and strikes him and cares nothing for the festival, for the laws, for your opinion, or for the god’s honor.


Intertexts (texts cited often on the same page as the searched text):

1 results
1. Demosthenes, Orations, 21.8-21.10, 21.12, 21.42, 21.45, 21.47-21.48, 21.51-21.61, 21.150 (4th cent. BCE - 4th cent. BCE)



Subjects of this text:

subject book bibliographic info
barbarian/barbaros Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
chaereas Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
charisius Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
demosthenes Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
father-son relations Humphreys, Kinship in Ancient Athens: An Anthropological Analysis (2018) 153
fury, cf. anger gall, cf. bile gender Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
hero, comic hero Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
hero Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
law, athenian. Gagarin and Cohen, The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Greek Law (2005) 206
lawgiver Gagarin and Cohen, The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Greek Law (2005) 206
lease, orgeones Humphreys, Kinship in Ancient Athens: An Anthropological Analysis (2018) 153
mantitheos Humphreys, Kinship in Ancient Athens: An Anthropological Analysis (2018) 153
marriage Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
meidias Gagarin and Cohen, The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Greek Law (2005) 206; Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
mining Humphreys, Kinship in Ancient Athens: An Anthropological Analysis (2018) 153
mnesibulus Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
pamphile Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
political theory, and law. Gagarin and Cohen, The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Greek Law (2005) 410
rhetoric' Gagarin and Cohen, The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Greek Law (2005) 206
shame Riess, Performing interpersonal violence: court, curse, and comedy in fourth-century BCE Athens (2012) 350
slaves, manumission Humphreys, Kinship in Ancient Athens: An Anthropological Analysis (2018) 153
trierarch Humphreys, Kinship in Ancient Athens: An Anthropological Analysis (2018) 153